After more than 40 years of building businesses and working with leadership teams, I’ve heard the same frustrations over and over again. Employees aren’t listening. There’s too much gossip. Nobody takes accountability. Office politics are getting in the way of getting things done.
And often, the conclusion is that we simply have the wrong people.
We need better employees. Better managers. Better hiring practices. We need to get the right people in the right seats.
But here’s what I’ve come to understand over the years. More often than not, the problem isn’t character. It’s culture.
And culture starts with leadership.
Every business has a culture, whether anyone has intentionally created it or not. If you haven’t taken the time to define what your organization stands for, what behaviours are acceptable and how people are expected to work together, a culture will develop anyway. It just might not be the one you want.
One of the biggest mistakes leaders make is assuming that because they’ve communicated an expectation, everyone has agreed to it.
Think about something as simple as the office kitchen. The boss announces that everyone needs to clean up after themselves. Seems reasonable, doesn’t it? But a week later, there are dirty dishes in the sink and somebody’s forgotten lunch is growing something interesting in the fridge.
Now everyone’s complaining, nobody’s taking responsibility and the boss is frustrated.
The issue isn’t necessarily that people are irresponsible. It’s that an instruction was given without creating a shared agreement about what responsibility actually looks like.
There’s a difference.
When we work with teams to establish their culture, we start by getting people involved in the conversation. What kind of environment do we want to work in? What are we willing to tolerate? What does accountability mean? What does gossip mean? How do we handle disagreements?
Those conversations matter because what seems like common sense to one person might mean something completely different to another.
Steffany experienced this firsthand through her work with Ice Academy Montreal, where elite athletes from competing countries train together. These are individuals with different backgrounds, languages, ambitions and expectations. Yet they can operate within a shared environment because they’ve participated in defining what that environment stands for.
That brings me to another idea worth challenging. We’ve all heard that there’s no “I” in team.
Well, I disagree.
A team is made up of individuals, each bringing their own identity, strengths and contributions. The goal isn’t to eliminate individuality. It’s to create alignment around something bigger than any one person.
And here’s the important distinction. You don’t always have to agree, but you do have to align.
When people understand the culture, participate in defining it and commit to upholding it, accountability becomes a shared responsibility rather than something the boss has to constantly enforce.
That’s when things begin to change.
Leaders spend less time putting out fires. Team members understand what they’ve committed to. Expectations are clear, and people can hold one another accountable without every disagreement becoming a management problem.
Culture isn’t something you put on a poster in the lunchroom or write into an employee handbook and hope for the best.
It’s something you intentionally create, agree to and practise every day.
So the next time you’re frustrated with your team, before deciding you’ve hired the wrong people, ask yourself a different question.
Have we actually created the culture we’re expecting them to live up to?